Achhe Din: A Chimera


A Report Card on Modi government’s third year Experts analyse the performance of the various key ministries, including the PMO, Home, Defence, External Affairs, Agriculture, Skill Development, etc., and give marks

The man of destiny knows before anyone else that he has arrived. So did Modi well before 2014, when he became the Prime Minister of the most populous democracy in the world. Black money worth Rs 15 lakh per head will be back, he thundered. Two crore jobs will be created, he assured, and the youth found its political fatigue under decades of Congress rule being replaced by this new found political Viagra.

And yet, the more things changed, the more they remained the same. Political analysts may be wondering why the masses are mesmerised still, but the on-ground analysis of the ministries of this regime – including Modi’s own PMO - shows poor to abysmal delivery. One of the reasons is Modi’s complete dictatorial control over almost all but some minor ministries. Every minister, from finance, to defence, to external affairs, is just told to sign, or else…

As a result, the slogans that brought him votes, Skill India, Star-up India, Make in India, have remained but slogans. Homeland security has clearly been smashed with the audacious Chhattisgarh slaughtering of 25 CRPF soldiers by Maoists. Kashmir is totally out of the government’s hands. Manipur is burning…

India dreams of fighting China, but its major defence purchases are stuck, awaiting a four-star Chief of Defence Staff. And on the external affairs front, Modi snubbing the Chinese has made the Dragon even more determined to keep India out of the NSG. Even small, next-door neighbours like Nepal and Bangladesh have blasted India for its wrong policies. Indian railways, riding high on slogans such as Swachha Rail Mission, is back tracking on all fronts, though this is not stopping the government from boasting of a Bullet Train project, when the existing lines are giving up the ghosts.

Our experts, each with specific knowledge of the ministries, have had a few words of praise only for road transport and power ministries. The rest are best exemplified by Modi’s Madison Square Garden show: pyrotechnics and drum rolls of a showman!


Brilliance Trauma!

He is controversy’s favourite child. Either he puts his foot into his mouth with his comments or he is hounded by media and is portrayed as a crimin...


The Stormy Petrel

The leading ladies of Indian politics are apparently ahead of their male peers. Sonia Gandhi, president of the Indian National Congress, already has a...


Master of his own mind

Bhatta-Parsaul is a twin-hamlet at the other end of Greater Noida. It sprang up in the national media in May 2011 due to violent clashes between farme...


Zen of Politics

Varun Gandhi, son of Sanjay and Maneka Gandhi, is acutely aware that he has no entitlement that his cousins Rahul Gandhi and Priyanka Vadra have. He i...


Cornering Quotas

Globally, reservations of jobs, especially with the governments, and quotas in higher education, follow common trends. First, economic inducements nee...


Wretched of the Earth

“A positive wave of violence and despair began to grow. The outlaw anarchists shot at the police and blew out their own brains. Others, overpowered ...


Bada Bhim… Bahut Bada!

The sonic boom from that one resounding slap in a Saharanpur college echoed back from the sky and shook the entire northern Indian upper caste firmame...


Dalit Priests’ Tirupati Dream

Who gets the first darshan of the Lord of Seven Hills every day? Not the Brahman archakas (priests). But the Gollas (Yadavs, who are traditionally Da...